Climate change and the parks

Should Joshua Tree National Park allow the use of fixed climbing anchors in wilderness areas?/NPS file

Whether climbing anchors are appropriate in wilderness is a controversial issue Joshua Tree National Park staff is dealing with as it crafts a climbing management plan.

Back in January the park reached out for public comment on how it should manage climbing in the park. By the time the comment period had ended in mid-March, more than 4,000 responses had been received.

"Review of public scoping comments indicates fixed anchors in wilderness is a hot topic," a park release said this week. "Seventy-eight percent of the 4,184 correspondences had a comment on law and/or policy related to fixed anchors in wilderness. Comments ranged from concerns that in wilderness: all fixed anchors should be removed, all fixed anchors should be allowed, allow adding more fixed anchors, and everything in between."

The park does not have data on every climbing route or boulder problem, but an exhaustive review of Mountain Project and guidebooks provided documentation for 7,214 individual routes, the release noted. Here’s some beta on the data:

Are fixed anchors “installations” under the Wilderness Act?

NPS has determined that fixed climbing anchors, including bolts, are “installations” subject to Section 4(c) of the Wilderness Act. This conclusion is based on the definition of the term “installation” in  NPS Reference Manual 41: 2013 NPS Wilderness Definitions  and in common use and dictionaries.

NPS Reference Manual 41: Wilderness Stewardship Division (U.S. National Park Service) (nps.gov)

As installations, are all fixed anchors prohibited in wilderness areas?

Installations, including fixed anchors, are not flatly prohibited under the  Wilderness Act. Under Section 4(c) of the Wilderness Act, installations in wilderness are allowable if they are “necessary to meet minimum requirements for the administration of the area for the purpose of the Wilderness Act.” NPS uses a Minimum Requirements Analysis (MRA) to determine: (1) whether a specific activity is necessary for the administration of the wilderness area to realize wilderness purposes, and (2) what level of associated 4(c) use best preserves the qualities of wilderness character.

With respect to Step 1, NPS believes that providing climbing opportunities in Joshua Tree wilderness areas is a necessary activity to realize wilderness purposes. Climbing has a rich and important history of use both in and out of park wilderness areas, and climbing activities offer unique opportunities for solitude and primitive and unconfined recreation that are appropriate in wilderness areas and further wilderness values.

With respect to Step 2, NPS will analyze alternative levels of fixed anchor use and their effects on different aspects of wilderness character, including the “undeveloped” and “opportunities for primitive recreation” qualities, to determine what level of fixed anchor use best balances these qualities to accommodate wilderness-appropriate climbing activities.

No. This is consistent with NPS policy requiring a Minimum Requirements Analysis for all actions that may involve a use listed under Section 4(c) (installations, motorized vehicles, mechanical equipment, etc.). The NPS is simply applying these long-standing substantive climbing policies through the required MRA process to determine the appropriate level of fixed anchor use at Joshua Tree National Park.

NPS policy (NPS Director’s Order 41:  Wilderness Stewardship) recognizes that climbing is a legitimate and appropriate use of wilderness, stating that the occasional use of fixed anchors does not necessarily violate the Wilderness Act, but that “fixed anchors or fixed equipment should be rare in wilderness”, that “establishment of bolt-intensive face climbs is considered incompatible with wilderness preservation”, and that “climbing management strategies will address ways to control, and in some cases reduce, the number of fixed anchors to protect the park’s wilderness resources.” 

Park staff now moves on to crafting a draft environmental assessment around the climbing plan. It's expected to be released for public comment late this year or early in 2023.

A copy of National Parks Traveler's financial statements may be obtained by sending a stamped, self-addressed envelope to: National Parks Traveler, P.O. Box 980452, Park City, Utah 84098. National Parks Traveler was formed in the state of Utah for the purpose of informing and educating about national parks and protected areas.

Residents of the following states may obtain a copy of our financial and additional information as stated below:

Free webinar on May 17th 7 p.m. Eastern, 5 p.m. Mountain, and 4 p.m. Pacific

Join us for a discussion with the authors, Jonathan and Destry Jarvis. More info.

National Parks Traveler is a 501(c) (3) nonprofit media organization.

Privacy Policy Terms of Use